On behalf of Google and AOL, we brought and won a summary judgment motion of noninfringement on all asserted claims before Federal Circuit Judge Randall Rader sitting by designation.  The patent-in-suit was asserted against the Defendants in September, 2007 by Performance Pricing Inc., an Acacia entity.  Performance Pricing had accused Google’s AdWords and AOL's  Search Marketplace systems of infringing the patent, which involved a method of doing business over the Internet "wherein various forms of competition and/or entertainment are used to determine transaction prices between buyers and sellers.